Enterprise SAS SSD vs Consumer SSD

 The time was allocated to do a quick test to compare consumer grade SATA SSD drives to Enterprise grad SAS drives.   The SAS drives are 12Gbps, the SAS card is also 12Gbps.  The tests were done on the same Windows 10 desktop with the same LSI SAS card, expect where noted a PowerEdge r730 was used.

Baseline...Samsung Evo 840 1tb SSD on 12gb SAS controller, Windows 10

Samsung MZL1ls960 960gb SAS on 12gb SAS controller, Windows 10

Samsung MZL1ls960 960gb SAS on 12gb SAS controller, on Dell r730 PowerEdge on Perc H730 RAID card w/ 1gb cache, test set to 2gb, Windows Server 2019


Dell MZ-1LT3T8c 3.8tb SAS on 12gb SAS controller, Windows 10


Impressive results!  12gb SAS SSD drives are very near NVMe performance, and nearly double that of the SATA drives.  Is the performance due to having more cache?  Or is it because the SAS drives are 12Gbps vs 6Gbps on the SATA drives?  It should be noted that during testing the SAS drives consume roughly 2 more watts at idle 5 more watts during the test.   The SAS drives were also MUCH warmer to touch where the SAS drives were ambient temperature. 

No comments:

Post a Comment